Fish Passage Case Studies

East Armuchee Creek
Low-Water Crossing with Geocells

Case Study Contributors

  • Jim Kozik, Road Operations Engineer
  • Larry Holsomback, District Engineer Technician Chattahoochee-Oconee National Forest, US Forest Service

Location
Armuchee Creek Watershed, Chattahoochee-Oconee National Forest, Georgia, USA

Project Type

  • Low-water crossing
  • Geocells filled with gravel

Pre-Project Conditions

  • Chronic erosion at crossing causing sediment delivery to channel
  • History of storm damaged roads at stream crossings

Pre-Project Barriers
None

Watershed Characteristics

  • Drainage Area: 32 mi2 (82 km2)
  • Bankfull Width: 50 ft (15 m)

Ecological Value

  • Reduce sediment delivery from erosion
  • Maintain access to rearing habitat for bass, sunfish, dace, and madtoms
  • Species of concern include Redeye bass, Coosa darter, and Alabama rainbow (freshwater mussel).

Project Characteristics

  • Low-water crossing 40 ft (12 m) long, 16 ft (4.9 m) wide utilizing a polyethylene, honeycomb-like structure (geocells) filled with stone
  • Stream channel: 8 in (20 cm) thick geocells underlain with geofabric and filled with quarry rock
  • Crossing approach: 8% grade with 4 in (10 cm) thick geocells filled with quarry rock

Challenges

  • Entrenched streambanks and moderately erosive soils
  • Narrow low-standard road making delivery of materials challenging
  • Need to control traffic at approaches to prevent widening of crossing

Project Contributor
US Forest Service

Project Funding
US Forest Service

Completion Date
1990

Total Project Cost

Materials $ 8,000
Construction $ 2,000

Total $ 10,000


Project Summary

This low-water crossing was experiencing chronic erosion as drivers widened the approaches due to the deepening of the stream at the crossing location. To stabilize the crossing and improve safety the low-water crossing was reconstructed using geocells; an expandable three-dimensional polyethylene, honeycomb-like structure that is placed on top of a geotextile fabric laid across the stream channel. The cells are 4 in (10 cm) deep on the approaches and 8 in (20 cm) deep across the channel. They are filled with gravel to provide a stable driving surface that retains a roughened bottom to the stream channel. The use of the geo-cells for low-water crossing applications were first tried on this Forest in 1986, and summarized in the January-February 1987 edition of Engineering Field Notes, published by the US Forest Service.

This project was the first in a series of low water crossings within the watershed. The second utilized concrete planks and the newest utilized linked concrete blocks.


Post Project Observations

Crossing has been in use continually for over 17 years and has survived numerous large storm events. The downstream edge of the crossing remains at grade, and only a small riffle has formed. The roughness of the stone filled Geocells may help prevent water from accelerating and causing downstream scour, which often creates a drop along the downstream edge of the crossing. Fish likely have little to no difficulty swimming onto and across this low water crossing.

Along the upstream edge, portions of the geotextile fabric have come loose and need to be re-bedded. The top edge of cells have been worn down and raveled. Some additional stone needs to be added to fill in rock that has been scoured out. The crossing width needs to be restricted from further widening and approaches could use additional stone.


Lessons Learned

Construction and installation in the wet was difficult due to flowing water. Additional personnel and construction equipment, including a backhoe was needed. The cells should have been placed lower across the channel and the upstream edge of geo-textile should have been embedded into streambed to prevent it from becoming loose.

This type of low-water crossing appears well suited for low-volume roads crossing stable low-gradient channels.


Published 03/25/08